We started the And Justice for Al podcast with a dream: to dissect all things Pacino and be dazzled — or disgusted — along the way. And now we’ve been rewarded for our service with a true masterpiece: Al, Marty, Bob, and Joe have joined forces for The Irishman.

Does this team-up for the ages live up to the hype? Was anyone distracted by the CGI de-aging? And, most importantly, is Pacino worthy of the Academy Award nomination just recently bestowed upon him? We break it all down on maybe our most anticipated episode ever.

Don’t forget to subscribe to the In Reel Deep Podcast on iTunes and Stitcher!