Now that our best of 2018 lists are out in the world, it’s time to name the top movie of the year. Past winners have included Whiplash, Creed, Moonlight, and Get Out; what will we pick for 2018?

Before we choose between BlacKkKlansman, The Favourite, First Reformed, Roma, or A Star is Born, Andrew and Steve break down their respective top 10s and analyze a year where quantity topped quality and big moments took center stage. Then they get down to the nitty gritty; what’s the consensus no. 1? The only way to find out is to listen:

Theme music for this podcast is a sample of “The Outer Banks of Love” by Bruce H. McCosar, provided through Creative Commons. Don’t forget to subscribe to the In Reel Deep Podcast on iTunes and Stitcher!